Wednesday, 14 May 2008

Chantier Naval: The Truth Behind the Downfall of Zacchaeus Forjindam














Mr. Zacchaeus Forjindam and the Chantier Naval company he built from scratch. (Courtesy of CNIC)



By Louis Egbe Mbua



Mr. Zacchaeus Forjindam, the man who single-handedly built the Chantier Naval et Industriel du Cameroun (CNIC) from a scrap yard for disused marine equipment and vessels into an internationally reputed and fledgling potential industrial multi-national giant was unceremoniously dismissed from his position as General Manager of the State-owned company amidst confusion, accusations, counter-accusations of embezzlement, mishandled and unprofessional auditing procedures by his enemies; and allegedly bitter rivalry within the company insiders and outsiders. To this day, it is not quite clear as to the present veracity of opinions as it appears views are divided between his supporters: who see him as a Cameroonian champion of nation building and a Southern Cameroonian who has again taught French-speaking Cameroonian elite the art of nation-building, astute management and advanced technical and visionary thought.


On the other side of the argument are his enemies: those who saw his unnecessary and unwarranted stab at politics to deliver the much hated CPDM ruling party a victory in his home town of Santa, Southern Cameroons; and his disappointing support for Monsieur Biya, Le President de La Republique, for unconstitutionally staging a constitutional take over by fraudulently voting himself into power for life in the rubber stamp parliament. Others have claimed that his downfall was plotted by tribal demagogues of the Beti strain who disliked and envied Forjindam's successes they had never matched or cannot rival; and that they wanted him removed so that they may take over the company for themselves, their tribesmen and their families.


Whoever is right or wrong is not the question at this instant: the fact of the matter being that Forjindam was arrested soon after his dismissal by the Board of Directors of the company, 7 May 2008. He is presently locked up in La Prison Centrale de Douala au quartier New-Bell. The downfall of Forjindam is not only a great national tragedy for a man with such a supreme talent in management and engineering; but also a tremendous blow to Anglophone Cameroon's participation in Cameroon's developmental plans. Consequently, one has to meticulously examine the truth behind his alleged embezzlement of company's funds.


According to Cameroon French language daily, Quotidienmutations, the fall of the GM began when he secured almost £200 million from an international consortium of financial houses, including the African Development Bank, to expand CNIC into Victoria, Southern Cameroons, by building a world class Shipyard and a deep seaport in that city, http://www.cnicyard.com/. That Forjindam and his closest associates within the company "weaved a vast "network"of extortion of funds from the CNIC"; and that this was confirmed by Forjindam's brief hearing in front of the chief prosecutor.


The total amount "stolen" by Forjindam has not been fully brought to light nor his actual crime. Again, if we refer to Quotidienmutations, 09 May 2008, it is alleged that cheque payments of almost £600,000 were noted to have been made without proper documents to back the funds. The paper did not say who banked these cheques; and on whose account were the cheques deposited; and also where exactly the money came from. Secondly, there were also cheques deposited to the bank to the tune of almost £180, 000, but which were not recorded in the bank's accounts. Again, whose account were these cheques deposited and who, exactly, deposited these cheques is not clear. Thirdly, another situation of withdrawal of almost £220, 000 from the bank "without sufficient verifiable or justifiable documents". In addition, it was discovered that there were fictitious names on the CNIC's payroll -- workers who didn't exist. If this is found to be true, then this, clearly, is corruption. The total amount in question, therefore, amounts to about £1,000, 000 (one million GBP). Which begs the question as to who owned this money; and from whose account was the theatrical financial drama acted. Was it from the CNIC account or was it from Forjindam's? And what, exactly, do they mean by "insufficient justifiable documents" as related to the deposit or withdrawal of money? These are the crucial questions that must be answered.


Forjindam's fall is a classic example of the kind of unaccountable and undemocratic politics that prevails in Africa. Born in 1949, Forjindam attended CPC Bali, from where he won an American scholarship to the famed Cameroon College of Arts, Science and Technology, Bambili. Having obtained his degree in Engineering from Fourah Bay University College in Sierra Leone, he worked in a maritime company in France before returning to Cameroon to work for the Cameroon Shipyard; at that time an unknown and penniless company. Installed in 1988 as GM of CNIC, he took the company to profitability and unprecedented expansion; delivering a profit of £8 million for a turnover of £40 million of business in 2007; took the workforce from 32 employees to 2500 people who earn their living at the Cameroon Shipyard and Engineering Company (CINC).
It must be noted that this achievement appears to be one of the first in Cameroon; and possibly Africa; and that many of Cameroon's state owned companies have either been looted of funds by corrupt party apparatchik managers or are on the verge of being bankrupted by the same incompetent party men. It is also interesting to note that the French-Speaking elite have always cast an envious eye on prosperous Southern Cameroons built institutions. One only hopes that his is not a repeat of a vicious cycle of Anglophone Cameroon hard work that may also end up in smoke as a result of the appointment of incompetent people to manage an organisation on the basis of "regional balance". When the Francophone elite took over the Anglophone-built Produce Marketing Board (PMO), one of the richest companies in the country at the time, it was not long before they looted and destroyed the company. The same goes to Cameroon Bank that was allegedly bankrupted by thieves pretending to be managers.


Forjidam's fall may also be of his own making. There was absolutely no reason for him to jump into politics in full with people who are corrupt, mad and bad. If at all, it turned out he committed a crime, it would be due to his own folly. There are reports that CPDM bosses of state companies raid state company accounts to sponsor elections which are heavily rigged on the promise of positions after the win of Paul Biya's party; CPDM. Forjindam, with such a huge talent, did not have to join the ranks of the mediocre and talentless technocrats to do the same. For his folly, his enemies found a web to weave around his mien; and then swallow him alive. On the other hand, if it is found that the auditing procedure was flawed and that Forjindam did no wrong, then he will be entitled to an unheard of financial compensation and a possible re-reinstatement to his old position or to that of another company of similar class. It is interesting to note that Forjindam returned profits and clean financial and managerial records for almost twenty years. For almost 2 decades, there is no evidence of embezzlement. Why then would he steal £1 million in the last 2 years? Mystery upon mystery.




















8 comments:

Anonymous said...

Hi Louis,
Nice to read your take on this issue. Forjindam like many Cameroonian "Grand Patrons D'Entreprises" is the architect of his own downfall. They treat public corporations like their private ventures; unaccountable, financially unscrupulous, and with the organizational skills of lunatics and the mindsets of thieves.

He was profligate, nepotistic and corrupt. Whatever the political machinations are that lie behind his arrest, they are minimal in comparison to his felonous activities that warranted his arrest. It was long time overdue.

He was just as corrupt as the next "big man". A tribalist to the core, with a massive chip on his shoulder; for big political benefits and large expectations for his loyalty to a corrupt dictatorial regime. When you lie with dogs, you wake up with fleas. Forjindam is just one of the first of Anglophones whose necks are on the chop. Remember what happened to his "brother at the ports" who sacked but not arrested, after his spate of corruption?

Now, his arrest has left not only an administrative void at the top, but at the lower reaches too.

Biya's government is rotten, and he is surrounded by greedy and callous hangers-on. Forjindam is a casualty of his own greed and profligacy. May he never leave Kondengi.

Anonymous said...

Sorry sir but your lame attempts to absolve Forjindam is just that, lame. Anyone who will take to the pulpit to call for a life presidency for Biya is a man without integrity and doesn't deserve any respect and must have skeletons in their closet and Forjindam cannot be any different.
The fact that he might made a profit is irrelevant. How much of it did Forjindam steal. Did he fail to pass-on Biya's share?. Poor soul. Just when he thought Biya would co-opt him for flag-bearing CPDM campaign for crowning King Paul the first.
sorry sir, Forjindam is where he should be. Can't wait for the day Biya would join him.

Louis Mbua said...

Dear Sirs,

Thank you all for the input and intelligent reponses. I am in no way trying to absolve Forjindam or approve of fraud and theft of state funds. Nor does one condone his alleged immoral/moral actions as GM of CNIC.

In composing the posting I tried to separate Forjindam, the professional Engineer from the Manager. The tribesman from the politician; and his ultimate political folly and downfall.

What ever our diverse views about this saga, we may all agree that he was a talented engineer.

The same cannot be said of his political talents. If it turned out to be true that he stole money from the company; and that he introduced fictitious names into CNIC pay roll, then he must serve his time in prison for fraud and theft.

Thanks again for the brilliant contribution to the debate on corruption in Cameroon.

Mbua

Unknown said...

Hi ,

Since Forjindam's fall it appears a tirade of articles bordering on macheavillan conspiracy theories have popped out from anglophones.

What bothers me is the impression that anglophones think by merely being anglophone one is absolved from having wrecked the nation.

Separating Forjindam the man, the politician, the manager, the engineer, the father and whatever is a sign of the distasteful perception of anglophones about themselves.

It is certainly easier to swallow when Siyam Siewe, or Abah Abah go down the drain. As if they were not talented in certain domains, just as is the case with dear Mr Forjindam.

As to his supposed artlessness in politics... I dare some of the posters to come home and practise a different brand.

Anonymous said...

Hello Isat,

It would be a mistake to "swallow" Siewe and Abah Abah without acknowledging their own various “talents”. This has very little to do with Anglophone – Francophone endless remonstrations. The trouble here is that it would seem the achievements of the two gentlemen you quoted as examples to rival Forjindam's own professional heroism; were totally eclipsed by their propensity to embezzle sums far greater than their respective company or departmental budgets. Consequently, their talents must register, at best a zero sum contribution to national development; and at worst an utterly negative, harmful, retrogressive and detrimental presence in public life.

If what Forjindam did wrong is true; we must all condemn it and let justice take its course for no man has the right to commit fraud or steal even £1000. On the other hand we must weigh people in the balances to reach the right judgement. To reduce such social dynamics to mere Anglophone -Francophone rivalry is a point of missing the smaller prints of the saga.

Further, there is evidence that Anglophone institutions were ruined by Francophone elite. We must face the truth to sort out the national disgrace of corrupt management practices and foolish discrimination in Cameroon that has brought is this new problem of constitutional fraud and economic retrogression.

Finally, you gave eulogiums of Abah and Siewe without saying exactly what talents they displayed in their various professions in public life before they were arrested and imprisoned for theft of public funds. Remember that obtaining a University qualification is one thing; and applying that knowledge to benefit society, which is displaying talent, is another matter altogether.

Anonymous said...

Ladies and Gentlemen, you dont have to be a brain surgeon to figure out that the former General Manager of CNIC was framed. Its obvious that ficticious evidence was used to undermine his manegerial skills. Isn't it a tad bit ironic that the basis of Mr. Forjindams arrest was a fraudulent audit conducted by Mr. Charles Kooh II- an auditor by day and con artist by night?? You see back in 2006,Mr Kooh was arrested and sent to Kondengui central prison for malpractice, embezzling public funds, producing false reports and distorting accounting facts at another state corporation that hired him. So the question we all have to ask ourselves is, why would anyone in their right mind believe an audit report from a shady auditor who was fired from his own company (Price Waterhouse & Coopers) for dishonesty and professional misconduct? Mr Forjindam was denied justice once before.lets all pray that this time around as he appeals his case, the judges do the right thing and allow justice to prevail.

~ Freedom Writer

Anonymous said...

I LOVE WHAT YOU HAVE DONE WITH THE PLACE <3 p.s is it true you is a robot innit.

Anonymous said...

Kyle Roberts wants to suck your pee pee, he thinks you have a large pee pee, he wants to be your wife. - Bradley Acton. Space studio west London